AGR-144
THE NATURE AND VALUE OF RESIDUAL SOIL FERTILITY
ISSUED: 1-90
REVISED:
W.O. Thom
Department of Agronomy
What nutrients does a particular soil
have before fertilizer is added? To answer this question, agronomists refer
to residual soil fertility, the level of available plant nutrients which
a soil can provide without additional fertilization.
A high residual level can occur for several reasons:
•Prolonged application of fertilizers
beyond crop needs.
•Naturally high levels of plant nutrients
in soils. For example, soils in the Inner Bluegrass region are high in
phosphate because they were formed from highly phosphatic limestones.
Residual soil fertility can also be low for several reasons:
•Prolonged cropping without adequate
fertilization.
•Naturally low levels of plant nutrients
in soils. For example, low phosphorus levels are often found on unfertilized
soils formed from low phosphate parent materials.
In any case, knowing the residual fertility
level of soil is important to determine if fertilizers are necessary for
economically optimum crop production.
Composition
Residual soil fertility consists of "residual pools" of
•nutrients in the organic matter,
•exchangeable nutrients,
•slowly soluble chemical compounds,
•nutrients in the soil mineral fraction.
Plant availability of residual fertility is affected by many factors,
including
•the release of plant nutrients from
the soil's mineral and organic fractions by dissolution and decomposition,
•past fertilization practices,
•past cropping history.
Soil Testing as an Indicator
The science of soil testing has been developed through long-term research
to:
•more accurately measure residual levels
of available soil nutrients (soil test levels);
•more precisely relate crop response
to available nutrients;
•determine fertilizer needs.
Figure 1
shows how residual soil fertility affects crop yield. When fertilizer is
added to soil with very low or low residual fertility, larger yield increases
can be expected. In contrast, little or no fertilizer is needed for maximum
crop yields after residual soil fertility has been built to, or exists
at, the upper medium or high levels.
Soil testing methods usually measure two things about each nutrient:
•all of the plant available form, (exists
in the soil solution around soil particles and comprises a very small part
(.01 to 1%) of the total in the soil).
•portions of the organic, exchangeable
and slowly soluble forms.
Residual soil fertility is commonly
defined as the amount of nutrient reported in the soil test plus some variable
amount expected to become available during the crop season from the nutrient's
organic, exchangeable and slowly soluble forms. The residual forms are
reservoirs which can replenish the plant available form during the growing
season, as plant uptake removes nutrients from the soil solution.
The chemical solutions used in soil
testing extract variable amounts of the residual forms, depending on the
nutrient. Most of the residual forms extracted can easily become plant
available and thus can directly influence how much nutrient exists in the
plant available form. Because of this relationship, soil test results are
often used to measure residual soil fertility.
Adjusting Residual Fertility
Changes in residual soil fertility
occur as nutrients are added or removed from the soil. Nutrients can be
added by
•crop residues,
•manures,
•agricultural lime,
•fertilizers.
Nutrients can be removed by
•harvested crops,
•soil erosion,
•leaching.
When additions are greater than removals,
the residual fertility increases, and likewise, when removals exceed additions,
residual fertility decreases.
Increasing Residual Fertility
Residual soil fertility is increased
as a result of prolonged application of a nutrient from any source that
exceeds nutrient removed in cropping. Or, it can be increased by a single
large application of nutrients from fertilizer, manure or lime. In these
cases, the extra nutrients become part of the residual forms, resulting
in increases in soil test values.
However, soil test levels do not change
on a pound-for-pound basis when extra fertilizer is added. Several factors
influence how these soil test levels change:
•soil type,
•clay type,
•relative level of the soil test when
the large addition occurred. (When soil test values are low, it takes more
fertilizer to raise the values per unit of added fertilizer than when soil
test values are high.)
•how deeply the applied lime or fertilizer
material is mixed.
Table 1 illustrates this relationship
for a Belknap silt loam in western Kentucky. Different soil types have
somewhat different numerical values for each soil test value but the general
relationship (decreased amounts of excess nutrient required for increasing
soil test values) is the same.
Table 1. - Amounts of excess addition over removal required to change
soil test P or K (lb nutrient/lb soil test) at a given soil test, Belknap
silt loam.
| Soil test P |
P2O5 Required |
Soil test K |
K2O Required |
| lb/A |
lb P2O5/lb P |
lb/A |
lb K2O/lb K |
| 10 |
14.5 |
100 |
6.4 |
| 20 |
10.3 |
150 |
5.4 |
| 30 |
8.4 |
200 |
4.7 |
| 40 |
7.3 |
250 |
4.2 |
| 50 |
6.5 |
300 |
3.8 |
Adding organic matter (manures or crop
residues) to soil can also increase residual fertility. However, the crop
can benefit from this source only as it is released when the organic matter
decomposes. The rate and amount of nutrient release depends on residue
type, temperature, soil moisture, soil type, aeration, soil pH and tillage
method. Most increases occur quite slowly over years and some equilibrium
is reached after several years depending on changes in the soil management
factors. For example, no-till allows more accumulation of crop residue
on the surface compared to conventional tillage. Thus no-till temporarily
reduces release of some nutrients for a few years. After equilibrium is
established, (nutrient addition equals nutrient release), greater amounts
of plant available nutrients are released.
Soil test values from these soils that
are built to a high level of residual fertility can often support several
years of cropping without fertilizer application.
Recommendations
Sample and retest soils high in residual
fertility every 3 to 4 years. Doing so is especially important for cropping
rotations that remove large quantities of potassium (tobacco, corn silage,
alfalfa and other forages) or when soil test P and K levels are not more
than 25% above the values needed for no additional phosphate and potash
fertilizer.
Reducing Residual Fertility
Residual fertility decreases when net
nutrient removal occurs. This situation may happen when no additional nutrients
are applied or when few crop residues are returned to a soil. For nutrients
determined by soil test, it follows that a high soil test value decreases
faster than a low soil test value. Table 1 shows that lesser amounts of
P2O5 and K2O are required to increase
the soil test when values are higher, so the soil test decreases at a faster
rate at high values. Example: With 60 lb P2O5/ac
removal, soil test P would decrease about 9 lb/ac at 50 (60 divided by
6.5) but only about 4 lb/ac at 10 (60 divided by 14.5).
The residual fertility in organic form
can be drastically reduced when you switch from a more reduced tillage
method to a conventional tillage method (moldboard plowing, disking or
chiseling). Such a change results in greater residue incorporation, or
breaking of larger residue into smaller pieces, which temporarily speeds
decomposition rate. More nutrients become plant available, thus reducing
the organic residual pool.
Periodic Large Nutrient Applications
Fertilizers and manures are sometimes
applied in large amounts once every 2 or 3 years and agricultural lime
may be applied only every 3 to 5 years. This practice causes nutrients
to build up during the year of application, and some undecomposed or undissolved
nutrients carry over to compensate for crop removal before another application.
If the excess nutrients exceed crop removal, then residual fertility is
increased.
In succeeding years when no fertilizer
is applied, the higher amounts from the first year are then reduced by
crop removal in succeeding years and the residual soil test values decrease.
With such immobile nutrients as phosphorus, zinc and molybdenum, a large
application may have a residual effect for up to 10 years. Use of crop
residues and manures can also add to residual levels because they do not
completely decompose in a single crop season, but carry over some nutrients
for succeeding years.
How Residual Fertility Affects Choice of Application Methods
At Low Residual Fertility
At low residual fertility (low soil
test values) banding is more effective than broadcasting. However, with
medium to high residual fertility, the methods are about equal.
Why
At these low levels, proportionately
more of the applied nutrients become fixed into less available forms than
in soils with high residual fertility. This effect is particularly evident
when nutrients are broadcast applied. Because of this situation, banding
of fertilizers increases fertilizer efficiency at low residual fertility
levels of the immobile nutrients and application rates can often be reduced
from those recommended for broadcasting.
Examples
At low residual levels of P and K,
banded fertilizer can be from 1.5 to 3 times more effective than broadcast.
Tobacco leaf yields have responded economically to banding of potassium
containing fertilizers up to a medium to high residual level in the soil.
Temperature Effect
Some crops, like early planted corn
and late-fall seeded small grains, may show higher banding efficiencies
when soil and air temperatures are cool for long periods after seeding.
However, at medium or above residual levels there is little difference
in crop use between the two methods if soil temperatures are normal during
early crop growth.
At High Residual Fertility
When residual fertility levels are
high (high soil test values), it is generally immaterial when fertilizer
is applied (except N sources) in relation to crop growth, or what method
is used for nutrient application since there will likely be no crop response
anyway.
Recommendations
Using soil test results for most nutrients
is the best guide to determine when nutrients are needed and the rate necessary
to provide for an economic growth response.
Economics of Residual Fertility
From an economic standpoint, apply
nutrients to a soil only if they will result in a profitable yield increase.
When soils have high residual fertility, either naturally or due to buildup
from prolonged use of excessive fertilizer, in most years yields will not
increase with further addition of those nutrients. These soils can be cropped
for several years without any further nutrient addition before residual
fertility drops to responsive levels.
Fertility recommendations made by the
Kentucky Cooperative Extension Service are based on the principles found
in this publication.
Patterns of Residual Fertility in Kentucky
Residual fertility of Kentucky soils
is quite variable. However, residual fertility has increased strongly during
the past 25 years as fertilizer use increased. Tables 2 and 3 show the
distribution of soil samples by residual fertility level according to the
crop for which the field was to be used for 1975 and 1985.
Table 2 -Percent of phosphorus soil test values in each category
in 1975 and 1985 for soils to be planted to important crops in Kentucky.
|
Crop Year |
Soil P test category1
|
No. Samples |
| VL |
L |
M |
H |
VH |
|
% of samples found in each group
|
| Burley tobacco |
1975 |
9 |
7 |
12 |
7 |
65 |
4365 |
| 1985 |
2 |
6 |
12 |
8 |
72 |
7461 |
| Corn |
1975 |
33 |
17 |
21 |
7 |
23 |
3940 |
| 1985 |
3 |
20 |
33 |
13 |
31 |
9869 |
| Soybeans |
1975 |
43 |
22 |
20 |
6 |
9 |
1341 |
| 1985 |
3 |
21 |
35 |
15 |
26 |
3322 |
| Alfalfa |
1975 |
25 |
14 |
22 |
9 |
30 |
909 |
| 1985 |
4 |
20 |
23 |
11 |
42 |
4506 |
| Grass-legume forage |
1975 |
58 |
12 |
12 |
4 |
14 |
6464 |
| 1985 |
14 |
33 |
20 |
8 |
25 |
5744 |
1Bray no. 1-VL << 15 lb/acre, L = 15-30, M = 30-60,
H = 60-80, VH > 80.
Table 3. Percent of potassium soil test values in each category in
1975 and 1985 for soils to be planted to important crops in Kentucky.
|
Crop Year |
Soil K test category1
|
No. Samples |
| VL |
L |
M |
H |
|
% of samples found in each group
|
| Burley tobacco |
1975 |
9 |
25 |
47 |
17 |
4365 |
| 1985 |
6 |
20 |
45 |
29 |
7463 |
| Corn |
1975 |
25 |
46 |
24 |
5 |
3940 |
| 1985 |
12 |
34 |
43 |
11 |
9869 |
| Soybeans |
1975 |
30 |
49 |
18 |
3 |
1341 |
| 1985 |
10 |
36 |
44 |
10 |
3322 |
| Alfalfa |
1975 |
20 |
39 |
33 |
8 |
909 |
| 1985 |
12 |
30 |
42 |
16 |
4507 |
| Grass-legume forage |
1975 |
30 |
44 |
21 |
5 |
6464 |
| 1985 |
16 |
34 |
37 |
13 |
5742 |
1NH 4 OAC-VL<<75lb/acre,L=75-165,M=165-250,H>250.